I got the xxl, following the size chart (41" waist and 49" hip). Initially I really liked the short, though it is just a touch snugger in the waist than I think is desirable for lounge wear. What changed my mind from "love" to "like" is that after extended wear (1+ hours) the elastic waist band at the back started folding at the top. It then felt like I had to constantly smooth the waist band out to get comfortable, which just isn't comfy! For plus sizing I feel like the grade needs to be a touch bigger and the elastic needs to be 1/4 inch to 1/2 inch narrower. If you have a tummy, you don't want the waistband constantly folding on you. And with this width, the only way to keep it up is a firmer elastic which would also affect comfort. I would buy again if adjustment was made to the plus size fit. I did experience great customer service and response.